PAID IN FULL – Private Student Loan 1 (PSL1) / Was the balance transfer worth it?

When I logged in this morning to pay off the remainder of Private Student Loan 1 (PSL1), I didn’t really “feel” anything after I paid off the remainder of the balance transfer. So then I logged into the original creditor’s website and saw the above landing page. A year ago when I saw this when I transferred the balances from my lender to two separate credit cards I felt excited to have a plan but the image above didn’t really resonate with me. My loan wasn’t actually “paid in full.” Today, it feels a bit different. This was the last student loan I took out (will ever take out!) and it felt significant to pay it off. Not like I erased the years and made better decisions significant, but significant to the extent that it represents me recovering from my poor financial choices and moving forward.

Private Student Loan 1 Payment Recap 

This loan was targeted for repayment first because while it had an average balance with respect to my other student loans, it had a ridiculous interest rate for a student loan. From January to March of 2019, it peaked at 10.115%! To highlight how ridiculous this student loan rate was, consider that the credit card to which I transferred most of the balance, my Discover It Card, only has a interest rate of 11.99%. Yes, my student loan interest rate was within two percentage points of my credit card interest rate.

As this was significantly higher than any of my other student loans and combined with the emotional pull of it being the last (and in my eyes the most frivolous) student loan I took out, it was an easy choice.

Minimum Payment: $110.46

-$10,231.32 – Balance on July 4th when I started this blog AND began targeting this loan
-$9,812.49 – August 1, 2019 balance
$10,145.50 Balance after balance transfer to credit cards; new amount includes balance transfer fees of $295.50 (and an over-payment of $32.21)
-$9,919.10 – September 1, 2019 balance
-$9,550.00 – October 1, 2019 balance
-$9,225.00 – November 1, 2019 balance
-$8,800.00 – December 1, 2019 balance
-$8,600.00 – January 1, 2020 balance
-$8,400.00 – February 1, 2020 balance
-$7,200.00 – March 1, 2020 balance
-$6,100.00April 1, 2020 balance
-$3,700.00 – May 1, 2020 balance
-$2,800.00 – June 1, 2020 balance
-$2,350.00 – July 1, 2020 balance
-$1,900.00 – August 1, 2020 balance
$0.00 – August 3, 2020 balance; will be reflected in student loan balance update on September 1st

Total interest saved: $522.00
Balance transfer fee: $295.50
Actual amount saved (interest saved – balance transfer fee): $226.50

Was the balance transfer worth it?

In the grand scheme of things $226.50 doesn’t seem like a lot of money. However, that is also $226.50 of my own money that I didn’t have to give someone else. And if I was asked to spend $226.50 on something at this very moment, I could not think of what I would spend it on… So financially, was it worth it? The answer has to be “yes.”

However, unless I paid of my loan really quickly, then that was always going to be the case. There was more than likely going to be some savings from the balance transfer. In an earlier post, I reviewed the benefits both financially and psychological to the balance transfer. In that post, the take-a-way is that most of the benefits of the balance transfer would appear to be psychological, and in reality, I found that very much to be the case. If you look at my repayment log above, I didn’t really get serious about paying off this balance and pushing myself hard to make big payments until February/March of this year. Why? Because I realized the balance transfer would be ending soon and that I needed to make big payments if I had any hope of paying it off (AND being a balance transfer “failure” and avoiding the embarrassment of having to write a post about it). This forced me to make sacrifices and adhere more strictly to my budget to make those big payments. While this was good for my student loan balances, it also had the additional psychological benefit of making $1,000.00/month additional debt payments seem “doable,” whereas before they were just something I could do in theory. Now, every dollar spent that takes me further away from being able to make a $1,000.00 payment on the first of the following month feels real and like I failed a bit. So when I make that $700.00 additional payment, I no longer think about getting a reward for my sacrifice, instead, I now think, “I could have paid more. I have previously paid more.” That shift in mindset is invaluable. So, was it worth it from a psychological perspective? An emphatic “yes.”

Would I do it again?

I don’t know. While that might seem a bit surprising given my answers above, it really shouldn’t be. The current financial environment is much more fraught that it was a year ago. I didn’t feel like I had the flexibility to decelerate my student loan payments toward this debt because of the balance transfer which means I didn’t start to increase my savings in response to the pandemic. While that is now my plan, had I not had the balance transfer, I think I would have done this much, much sooner. While the current pandemic is unprecedented, it highlights how drastically your financial situation can change very quickly and highlights the principle downside to the balance transfer method: the loss of financial flexibility.

4 thoughts on “PAID IN FULL – Private Student Loan 1 (PSL1) / Was the balance transfer worth it?

  1. Hi there, I started reading your blog after seeing that C at The Single Dollar recommended you on Twitter. I was sad when she ended her blog, and I’m so happy to have found yours. I find the very detailed listing of balances, minimum payments, etc. very interesting and inspiring. I’m a couple of decades older than you, and my financial situation is different, but about ten years ago I started paying off my mortgage like crazy, and my current goal is to pay for my two children’s college educations without them having to take out any loans. They are a junior and a freshman in college. I have since sold the house whose mortgage I paid off, and bought a two-family, and I have an enormous new mortgage, but it’s offset by rent payments from my tenants. I’m single and live modestly and keep track of everything I earn and spend.

    I think you are doing an awesome job. It’s slow going at first, but you’re staying motivated, and you will only do better as time goes on and the debt continues to fall away. I bookmarked your site and I’ll look forward to reading your future posts!


    • Hello Ellen!

      First, C is wonderful and having her check-in with me every now in then helps me feel a bit less lonely and isolated on this debt repayment journey. I was also very sad when her blog went away. I am, however, grateful she connected us.

      Thank you for sharing a bit of your story with me. I hope to be where you are fiveish years from now. Maybe with a kiddo or two. I work for a university so I understand some of the challenges students are facing at this unprecedented moment in our history. I wish your children the best (especially the freshman) as they continue their education. Your housing situation sounds ideal and is definitely on my, “When this debt is all gone,” goal list.

      Thank you for the encouragement. You have no idea how much it means to me. Please feel free to connect at anytime.


  2. So happy for your progress and congrats on paying off your first loan! I remember paying off my first student loan and feeling the same exact way as you. Although I knew the journey was still long, after paying off that first loan I really felt like this mission was “doable” like you said. Take it from me, it’ll only go faster from here on out. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s